You think you're rational. You're not. You are constantly sabotaging your own decisions and arguments with these 5 sloppy thinking habits.
You think you are smart. You think you make decisions based on facts and logic. You think that when you argue with someone, you are the rational one and they are the emotional wreck.
I have bad news for you: You are wrong.
Your brain is a mess of shortcuts, biases, and glitches. You are constantly committing logical fallacies—errors in reasoning that make your arguments invalid and your decisions terrible. And the worst part? You probably don't even know you're doing it.
These aren't just abstract concepts for philosophy majors. These are mental traps that are ruining your relationships, your career, and your understanding of the world.
Here are the 5 most common offenders. It is time to stop using them.
1. The Ad Hominem (Attacking the Person)
What it is: Attacking your opponent's character or personal traits instead of engaging with their argument.
How you use it:
"You can't trust what he says about the economy; he cheat on his wife!"
"Of course you'd say that, you're a liberal/conservative/boomer."
Why it ruins your life:
It makes you impossible to talk to. When you attack the person, you admit that you have run out of actual arguments. You turn every disagreement into a fight. You dismiss valid points just because you don't like the messenger. This keeps you in an echo chamber where you never have to challenge your own views because you can just label everyone else as "bad."
The Fix: Attack the ball, not the player. Even a broken clock is right twice a day, and even a jerk can make a valid point.
2. The Straw Man
What it is: Misrepresenting someone's argument to make it easier to attack. You set up a fake version of their position (a "straw man") and knock it down, pretending you have won.
How you use it:
Friend: "I think we should fund public schools better."
You: "Oh, so you want to raise my taxes until I'm bankrupt just to throw money at a broken system?"
Why it ruins your life:
It destroys communication. You aren't actually listening to what people are saying; you are listening to a cartoon villain version of them in your head. You create conflict where there shouldn't be any. You spend your life angry at things people didn't actually say.
The Fix: "Steel man" their argument. Try to state their position better than they did before you argue against it. If you can't repeat their view back to them to their satisfaction, you don't understand it well enough to attack it.
3. The Sunk Cost Fallacy
What it is: Continuing a behavior or endeavor as a result of previously invested resources (time, money, or effort), even when it makes no rational sense to keep going.
How you use it:
"I've already spent 3 years in this degree I hate, I have to finish it."
"We've been dating for 5 years, I can't break up with him now, even though we're miserable."
Why it ruins your life:
This is the fallacy that keeps people in unhappy marriages, dead-end jobs, and bad investments. You characterize "quitting" as "waste," so you throw good money (or time) after bad. You let your past mistakes dictate your future happiness.
The Fix: Your past investment is gone. It is zero. The only question that matters is: "Would I start this today, knowing what I know now?" If the answer is no, walk away.
4. Confirmation Bias
What it is: The tendency to search for, interpret, favor, and recall information in a way that confirms your preexisting beliefs.
How you use it:
You only read news sites that agree with you. When you see a study that supports your view, you share it immediately. When you see a study that contradicts your view, you look for flaws in the methodology.
Why it ruins your life:
It makes you stupid. Literally. It prevents you from learning. It blinds you to reality. You become more and more certain about things you are actually wrong about. In a relationship, you only notice when your partner messes up (confirming they are lazy/uncaring) and ignore when they do good (which contradicts your narrative).
The Fix: actively seek out information that proves you wrong. Be your own devil's advocate. If you can't find a smart person who disagrees with you, look harder.
5. The Appeal to Nature
What it is: Arguing that because something is "natural," it is therefore valid, justified, inevitable, good, or ideal.
How you use it:
"I don't trust big pharma; I prefer natural remedies."
"Humans are naturally tribal, so war is just part of life."
Why it ruins your life:
Nature is not your friend. Nature tries to kill you constantly. Arsenic is natural. Hurricanes are natural. Cancer is natural. Meanwhile, antibiotics, eyeglasses, and central heating are thoroughly "unnatural." Relying on this fallacy leads to terrible health decisions and lazy moral justifications. Just because you have a "natural" urge to cheat or get angry doesn't make it right.
The Fix: Judge things by their evidence and their consequences, not their origin. "Natural" is a marketing term, not a moral standard.
Conclusion
Reasoning is a skill, not a talent. It takes practice. You have to watch your own brain like a hawk.
Stop letting these fallacies run your life. The next time you feel that surge of self-righteous anger, or that urge to dismiss someone, pause. Ask yourself: "Am I thinking, or am I just reacting?"
Your life will get better the moment you start actually using your brain.
LM
About Lyndon Marais
Founder and Solo Developer of The Secular Toolkit.
Write for us →